809 Nicholson Street, Carlton North, Victoria
It finally happened, Pie Nation. I fought it for years, but I’m just a weak pathetic human like the rest of the bootlicking press. You spend your entire life thinking you’re at least trying to be ethical and then when push comes to shove all your big words mean nothing.
I took a bribe. A bribe! Me! I feel dirty just typing it.
But hear me out. It was Friday night and I was sitting on the couch with a glassy-eyed stupor. Can’t remember what I was watching but it was some kinf of smooth-brain tv like Outlaw Beef Cops or We Locked 16 People With Knives In A Shipping Container, You know, the good shit.
“Babe,” I heard dimly through the miasma of clanking or mooing or whatever was being squirted into my ear-holes, “if you drive me to work in the morning I’ll buy you a pie. You can blog about it!” The bribe, you see, was mere promise of a pie that I had not yet tasted.
Zero resolve in me, I folded like a card table you got from the street during hard rubbish collection.
Next day, before my body even registered it was Saturday, we were driving down Nicholson Street when Mrs Pie pointed to where I needed to pull over. She exited the car, raced into Natural Tucker Bakery (peep their insta), and quick as a flash was back with a couple of piping-hot brown paper bags. They smelled incredible. I dropped her off at work, then returned home.
Their Beef Mince pie is up there with the greats — rich natural flavour with gravy that’s on the razor’s edge between being structural and falling into your lap. Eating it is like how I imagine it to be like if you learn to juggle knives, but the knives aren’t knives and they’re just the correct amount of salty.

The Beef and Mushroom was the standout though (yes I had two breakfast pies, I am a grown man, and I make my own choices). For mine, mushrooms can be a bit of a minefield in a dish. Get them right and they’re a fresh flavour that adds some sophistication to the texture, but get them wrong and they overpower everything. Get them even wronger and people do true crime podcasts from your trial.
You can see from the picture that this one was perfecto — the big portions of mushroom aren’t overcooked (sloppy, pungent) or too small (are you trying to hide them or something?). Really held the pie together in what I would describe as a Lebowskian manner.
Am I proud that I took a bribe? No. But am I pleased that I took that bribe? Hell yes.

Leave a Reply